American Lumpen or the Politicization of Ignorance

There is, I believe, a developing political movement of the uneducated by choice. By this I mean a flaunting of ignorance for political purposes with the intention of appealing to the ignorant as being just like them. Joe the Plumber and Sarah Palin are prime examples. To be ignorant is to be trustworthy.

Despite the fact that the founders of this country included a high incidence of intellectuals aware and engaged in the philosophy, science, economic and political thinking of the day, our country turned against intellectualism early in its history and it became fashionable to condemn intellectuals as “elitists.” Richard Hofstadter remarks this process in his book Anti-Intellectualism in American Life. Adlai Stevenson was so branded in my own time.

I suggest that the current form of politicized ignorance began with Richard Nixon's sending the Republican Party south to get the popular constituency it needed. This was done deliberately by a corporate America that had already moved the New England textile industry south to take advantage of cheap labor and anti-union state governments using a typically American contradictory euphemism, right to work laws. Hence we have the anomaly of the poor and middle class Southern whites in the service of the wealthy Northerners. Only in America!

The South, especially the Deep South, has been an intellectually backward part of this country since its founding, mainly because of racism. This continues today principally because Southerners are trapped by the guilt of pervasive racism. Because of this they remain very defensive. In effect they have no place to go intellectually. They cannot accept the human race as such and hence are not free to explore and understand the complexity of our species. The ascendency of the South in the Republican Party has made anti-intellectualism an unstated plank in the platform of that party. I should add that it is in the interests of the corporations that control the Republican Party to encourage rampant ignorance because people can more easily be seduced by advertising, both commercial and political, and by appeals to their emotions.

This process has resulted in one of the two major parties of this country promoting candidates who believe in creationism, deem global warming a conspiracy of the United Nations and a “Birthers” movement denying that President Obama was born in the United States This is more than folly, it is dangerous. A society with this number of people unhinged from reality becomes exceptionally vulnerable to manipulation. It confuses fact with belief and feels free to create “facts” that suit their motives. This is the kind of social mentality that permitted the rise of fascist regimes in Europe. I believe we can see this kind of ignorance in action in the current Republican-orchestrated ruckus at town hall meetings by Democratic Congressional representatives. This is the kind of bully boy tactic that the Nazis employed. In this respect it is also instructive to note that a prime mover of these attacks, Rush Limbaugh, has accused Obama of being a fascist. This kind of assertion by those who practice fascist techniques is done to preempt use of the term by applying it to their opposition first. Notice it is not the usual “commie” demonizing of the Republican past. The fact that these ludicrous, devious, misuses of language can be so effective is a measure of the degree the American public is removed from reality and thereby so profoundly gullible. That we are entering the throes of fascism is underscored in the article Is the U.S. on the Brink of Fascism? found at http://www.alternet.org/module/printversion/141819

Culturally, this can, I believe, be traced in significant part to the ascendency of the role of advertising in our society. The pervasiveness and insidiousness of 24/7 saturation of advertising, the application of advanced psychological knowledge to its development and the vast amount of fiscal resources available to it, have produced a citizenry increasingly incapable of distinguishing fact from fiction and therefore prone to accept the emotionally satisfying rather than the noetically verified. That this society is the most powerful on the planet does not bode well for our species.

Robert Newhard

Postscript: Bill Maher has an interesting take on the abysmal level of American ignorance at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bill-maher/new-rule-smart-president_b_253996.html?view